Skip to main content

Case Study · Motorcycle Accident

Motorcycle Left-Turn Collision: Full Liability Proven After the "Speeding" Defence

A rider hit by a left-turning driver, three surgeries and an insurer that blamed the motorcyclist. How camera footage and reconstruction evidence established full liability.

No win, no fee · Free consultation · Serving the Greater Toronto Area

The Short Answer

An experienced motorcyclist was hit by an oncoming driver turning left on a green light in Toronto, suffering compound leg fractures, a broken collarbone and road rash requiring skin grafts. The insurer claimed the rider was speeding. Traffic camera footage and an accident reconstruction proved otherwise, full liability was established on the driver, and the claim settled for compensation covering three surgeries, scarring, chronic pain and 14 months of lost income.

Quick facts

ClientExperienced motorcyclist (name and identifying details withheld)
LocationSignalized intersection, Toronto
CollisionOncoming vehicle turned left across the rider's path on a green light
InjuriesCompound leg fractures, broken collarbone, road rash requiring skin grafts
TreatmentThree surgeries, permanent hardware in the leg, extensive physiotherapy
Recovery14 months
LiabilityFull liability established on the left-turning driver
OutcomeSettled; amount confidential

The collision

Our client, an experienced rider, was travelling through a Toronto intersection on a green light when an oncoming driver turned left directly into their path. It is the most common serious motorcycle crash we see: a driver who looks, misjudges the speed or distance of an approaching motorcycle, and turns anyway. The impact caused compound fractures to the leg, a broken collarbone and road rash severe enough to need skin grafts.

The insurer's defence

The at-fault driver's insurer did not dispute that the turn caused the crash. Instead it ran two arguments that come up in almost every motorcycle case:

  • "The rider was speeding." The driver claimed the motorcycle was going too fast, aiming to establish contributory negligence and cut the payout by a percentage.
  • "The injuries aren't as bad as claimed." The insurer's biomechanical expert argued the injuries were less severe than the medical records suggested.

How we answered it

  • Traffic camera footage from the intersection established that our client was within the speed limit.
  • An accident reconstruction expert confirmed the turning driver did not have enough gap time to complete the left turn safely, which put the responsibility squarely on the turn.
  • An independent orthopaedic assessment documented the permanent hardware in the leg and our client's ongoing mobility limitations, answering the biomechanical report with clinical findings.

The result

Full liability was established on the at-fault driver, with no reduction for contributory negligence. The settlement included compensation for three surgeries, extensive physiotherapy, permanent scarring, chronic pain and significant income loss during the 14-month recovery. The amount is confidential.

What the claim covered

The value of a serious motorcycle claim is in the detail. In this case, the settlement had to account for:

  • Three surgeries and the hospital stays and recovery that came with them.
  • Extensive physiotherapy to restore strength and mobility around permanent hardware in the leg.
  • Permanent scarring from compound fractures and skin grafts, which carries its own weight in pain-and-suffering damages.
  • Chronic pain continuing after the fractures healed.
  • Significant income loss over a 14-month recovery.

Accident benefits from the rider's own policy funded treatment along the way, while the lawsuit against the at-fault driver recovered the losses benefits do not cover. The two claims run side by side, and decisions in one affect the other, which is why we manage both from the start.

Why left-turn crashes are so dangerous for riders

A motorcycle's narrow profile makes it harder for drivers to judge its speed and distance, and a driver focused on a gap in car traffic can simply fail to register an approaching bike. When the turn happens, the rider has a fraction of a second and no protective shell. That is why these collisions so often cause fractures, road rash and head injuries, and why the "I didn't see them" explanation is not a defence: a driver turning left must yield to oncoming traffic, and failing to see a vehicle that was there to be seen is the negligence.

What this case shows riders

  • The speeding allegation is standard. Expect it, and preserve the evidence that answers it: camera footage, your bike's damage pattern, helmet or dash-cam video, and witness accounts. Intersection and business cameras are often overwritten within days.
  • Medical documentation beats expert opinion. A biomechanical report is not a medical examination. Consistent treatment records and specialist assessments carry more weight.
  • Your own accident benefits come first. Riders claim accident benefits from their own motorcycle policy regardless of fault. For policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2026, only medical, rehabilitation and attendant care are guaranteed, so income loss may depend on the lawsuit. See our 2026 accident benefits guide.
  • Deadlines still apply. Notify your insurer within 7 days, file the OCF-1 within 30 days, and start any lawsuit within two years.

Learn more on our motorcycle accident lawyer page, our Mississauga motorcycle accident page, and all case results.

This case study is anonymized: the client's name and identifying details are withheld, and the facts and outcome are drawn from the firm's case record. Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in your case.

Olga Kanevsky, Toronto personal injury lawyer

Olga Kanevsky

LL.B, LL.M · Founder

About Your Lawyer

Two decades fighting for injured Ontarians

Olga Kanevsky is the founder of Kanevsky Law Office and has focused exclusively on Ontario personal injury law for more than 20 years. She holds a Bachelor of Laws (LL.B) and a Master of Laws (LL.M) from Osgoode Hall Law School, and is a member in good standing of the Law Society of Ontario (licence #51731A). Over her career she has recovered more than $50 million for injured clients and their families.

  • ✓ Licensed by the Law Society of Ontario (2001)
  • ✓ LL.M, Osgoode Hall Law School
  • ✓ $50M+ recovered for injured clients
  • ✓ Fluent in English, Russian & Ukrainian
  • ✓ Contingency fees — no win, no fee
  • ✓ Free, confidential consultations

Read Olga’s full profile →

Frequently Asked Questions

About This Case

Need more help? Free consultation · (416) 252-9937

Who is at fault when a car turns left into a motorcycle?+
Usually the left-turning driver, who must yield to oncoming traffic. Insurers often argue the rider was speeding to reduce the claim, which is why camera footage and reconstruction evidence matter.
Can my compensation be reduced if the insurer says I was speeding?+
Only if the insurer proves it. If the rider is found partly at fault, compensation is reduced by that percentage. In this case, traffic camera footage showed our client was within the speed limit and no reduction applied.
Do motorcyclists get accident benefits in Ontario?+
Yes. Riders claim statutory accident benefits from their own motorcycle policy regardless of fault. For policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2026, medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits are mandatory; income replacement depends on the coverage purchased.
Why is the settlement amount confidential?+
Many settlements include confidentiality terms, and we protect client privacy. The facts and outcome described are drawn from the firm's case record with identifying details removed.

Hit on Your Motorcycle?

Preserve the footage before it is erased. Free consultation, no fee unless we win.

4580 Dufferin St, Suite 309, North York, ON M3H 5Y2

Page last reviewed and updated: November 12, 2026 by Olga Kanevsky, LL.B, LL.M