Lawyer vs Paralegal
Lawyer or Paralegal for an Ontario Injury Claim? What Each Is Licensed to Handle
Both are licensed by the Law Society of Ontario, but only one can take a serious injury claim to the Superior Court. Here is exactly where the line falls.
No win, no fee · Free consultation · Serving the Greater Toronto Area
In Ontario, a licensed paralegal can represent you in Small Claims Court (claims up to $50,000) and in non-catastrophic accident benefits disputes at the Licence Appeal Tribunal. A lawyer is required for lawsuits over $50,000 in the Superior Court and for catastrophic impairment claims. Because car accident awards below $159,708.71 lose a $47,913.01 deductible in 2026, most worthwhile injury lawsuits need a lawyer.
Both are licensed, but they are licensed for different work
In Ontario, the Law Society of Ontario (LSO) licenses two kinds of legal professionals: lawyers (an L1 licence) and paralegals (a P1 licence). Both must meet education and character requirements, carry professional liability insurance and follow a code of conduct. The difference is scope. A lawyer can handle any legal matter. A paralegal can only act in the specific areas the Law Society permits, and for injury claims those limits are important.
What a licensed paralegal can do in an injury claim
- Small Claims Court. Paralegals can represent you in Ontario's Small Claims Court, which hears claims for money up to $50,000 (the limit rose from $35,000 on October 1, 2025).
- Accident benefits disputes that are not catastrophic. Paralegals can represent you at the Licence Appeal Tribunal in disputes with your own insurer over statutory accident benefits, such as a denied treatment plan or a Minor Injury Guideline dispute, as long as the claim does not involve a catastrophic impairment.
- Other provincial tribunals established under Ontario or federal law, within the Law Society's rules.
What a paralegal cannot do
- Sue in the Superior Court of Justice. Any claim worth more than $50,000 is brought in the Superior Court, where only lawyers can represent you. Most serious injury claims are in this category.
- Handle catastrophic impairment claims. Accident benefits claims involving a catastrophic impairment, with benefit limits up to $1,000,000, are outside a paralegal's licence.
- Run the litigation steps of a Superior Court case: examinations for discovery, pre-trial conferences and trial.
Side-by-side
| What you need | Licensed paralegal (P1) | Lawyer (L1) |
|---|---|---|
| Licensed and regulated by the Law Society of Ontario | Yes | Yes |
| Small Claims Court (claims up to $50,000) | Yes | Yes |
| Accident benefits dispute at the Licence Appeal Tribunal, non-catastrophic | Yes | Yes |
| Accident benefits claim involving catastrophic impairment | No | Yes |
| Lawsuit in the Superior Court of Justice (claims over $50,000) | No | Yes |
| Serious car accident, slip and fall or medical malpractice claim | Only if it fits in Small Claims | Yes |
| Wrongful death and family members' claims over $50,000 | No | Yes |
| Examinations for discovery, mediation and trial in Superior Court | No | Yes |
Why the $50,000 limit matters more in car accident cases
For motor-vehicle injuries, pain-and-suffering awards below $159,708.71 are reduced by a statutory deductible of $47,913.01 in 2026. A pain-and-suffering award of $50,000 therefore pays only about $2,087. In practice, car accident injury claims that fit within the Small Claims limit are rarely worth pursuing for pain and suffering, and the claims that are worth pursuing almost always need to be in the Superior Court with a lawyer. Slip-and-fall and other non-auto claims have no deductible, so a modest claim there can sometimes suit Small Claims Court.
When a paralegal can be a sensible choice
- A minor soft-tissue injury where the only dispute is a treatment plan or a Minor Injury Guideline decision with your own insurer.
- A small, non-auto claim with modest losses, such as a minor fall with a quick recovery, that clearly fits under $50,000.
- A property-damage dispute with no injury.
When you need a lawyer
- Any injury that is serious, permanent or still uncertain: fractures, disc injuries, concussions, chronic pain, surgery.
- Any claim against the at-fault driver in a car accident, because of the threshold and deductible.
- Possible catastrophic impairment, brain or spinal cord injury.
- Claims against a municipality, the province or a Crown agency, which carry special notice rules.
- Medical malpractice and wrongful death.
- Any case where future income loss or future care costs are part of the claim.
Choosing the wrong representative early can be expensive: if a claim turns out to be worth more than $50,000, it has to move to the Superior Court and a new representative has to catch up on the file.
How to check who you are dealing with
Search the Law Society of Ontario directory by name. It shows whether the person is a lawyer or a paralegal and whether their licence is in good standing. Olga Kanevsky is listed as a lawyer, licence #51731A. Be wary of anyone who approaches you at a collision scene, a tow yard or a hospital offering to "handle your claim", and of any arrangement you don't receive in writing. Every licensee must explain their fees in a written agreement.
Questions to ask before you hire anyone
- Are you a lawyer or a paralegal? Then confirm it in the Law Society directory.
- If my claim turns out to be worth more than $50,000, can you keep handling it? A paralegal cannot take it to the Superior Court.
- Who will actually work on my file? Ask whether you will deal with the licensee you met or be passed to staff.
- How are you paid? Ask for the fee arrangement in writing, including the percentage, how disbursements (expert reports, court fees) are handled, and what happens if the claim is lost.
- How many claims like mine have you taken to mediation or trial? Insurers know which representatives settle every file early.
- What deadlines apply to my claim right now? A good representative will name them at the first meeting: 7 days, 30 days, 60 or 10 days for notices, two years for the lawsuit.
How contingency fees work
Most injury lawyers in Ontario, including Kanevsky Law, work on a contingency fee: you pay no legal fee up front, and the fee is a percentage of what is recovered for you. If nothing is recovered, no legal fee is charged. Ontario requires the arrangement to be in a written agreement that explains the percentage and how costs and disbursements are treated, so you know before you sign what you will receive at the end. Compare carefully: a lower percentage is worth little if the claim is undervalued or cannot follow the case to the Superior Court.
How Kanevsky Law works
We are lawyers, so we can take a claim from the first accident benefits form through to trial. We act on a contingency fee with no up-front cost, and the first consultation is free. If your matter would be better handled in Small Claims Court or by a paralegal, we will tell you. See also Kanevsky Law vs big-firm volume mills and no win, no fee vs hourly fees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Lawyer or Paralegal: Quick Answers
Need more help? Free consultation · (416) 252-9937
Can a paralegal handle my car accident claim in Ontario?+
What is the Small Claims Court limit in Ontario?+
Can a paralegal represent me at the Licence Appeal Tribunal?+
Is a paralegal cheaper than a personal injury lawyer?+
How do I check if a lawyer or paralegal is licensed?+
Sources
- Law Society of Ontario directory (check any lawyer or paralegal licence)
- Small Claims Court Jurisdiction and Appeal Limit, O. Reg. 626/00 ($50,000 limit since October 1, 2025)
- Superior Court of Justice: Small Claims Court
- Licence Appeal Tribunal (accident benefits disputes)
- Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8 (threshold, deductible and income-loss rules)
Olga Kanevsky
LL.B, LL.M · Founder
About Your Lawyer
Two decades fighting for injured Ontarians
Olga Kanevsky is the founder of Kanevsky Law Office and has focused exclusively on Ontario personal injury law for more than 20 years. She holds a Bachelor of Laws (LL.B) and a Master of Laws (LL.M) from Osgoode Hall Law School, and is a member in good standing of the Law Society of Ontario (licence #51731A). Over her career she has recovered more than $50 million for injured clients and their families.
- ✓ Licensed by the Law Society of Ontario (2001)
- ✓ LL.M, Osgoode Hall Law School
- ✓ $50M+ recovered for injured clients
- ✓ Fluent in English, Russian & Ukrainian
- ✓ Contingency fees — no win, no fee
- ✓ Free, confidential consultations
Not Sure Who Should Handle Your Claim?
Ask a lawyer for free. If a paralegal or Small Claims Court is the better fit, we will tell you.
4580 Dufferin St, Suite 309, North York, ON M3H 5Y2